The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies 2014

影评 (18)

1. C

   clownhead 2026年8月23日

   plant your trees 🙁 watch them grow 🙁

   1,437
2. D

   DirkH 2026年8月23日

   I’ll start out by saying the exact same thing I said when reviewing The Desolation of Smaug, if you didn’t like the other films, don’t watch this one. It’ll be torture as Jackson approaches his material the exact same way as he does in the other films. I happen to love the first two parts. I am completely in tune with Jackson’s vision of Middle Earth and absolutely love and cherish the time he has allowed me to spend there. The Battle of the Five armies also, once again, confirms that we are not watching a mere adaptation of Tolkien’s novel, but a translation of the novel and other materials to transport it to the way Jackson envisaged The Lord…

   935 36
3. L

   Lucy 2026年8月23日

   lotr trilogy: a 3 course meal at a 5 star restaurant hobbit trilogy: a bad tv dinner cooked in the microwave

   1,757 6
4. L

   lottie🦕 2026年8月23日

   Legolas can’t have Tauriel so he goes off to find his boyfriend Aragorn instead

   2,561 12
5. 𝚮

   𝚮𝖆𝖗𝖑𝖊𝖖𝖚𝖎𝖓𝖆𝖉𝖊 🙏🏻 2026年8月23日

   Gandalf, over and over again: *discovers that shady shit is happening* *chooses to face it alone like a dramatic bitch* *gets tossed around like a rag doll* *sits in a cage for God knows how long* The eagles, Galadriel & Elrond, having to rescue him: Fucking hell, here we go again.

   960 5
6. M

   Matt Singer 2026年8月23日

   It takes a lot to make a war And even then it’s a total bore An eagle here, a big orc there But so what dude, who really cares? Too many armies Too many armies Too many armies Too many armies Too many armies Too many armies Too many armies (REPEAT FOR TWO HOURS OR UNTIL TIME FOLDS IN ON ITSELF, WHICHEVER COMES FIRST)

   927 6
7. B

   Buddy O 2026年8月23日

   Spend a whole movie hyping up Smaug then they kill him off in the first 10 minutes. -_-

   1,618 7
8. J

   Josh Lewis 2026年8月23日

   Legit one of the worst things that’s ever been projected in a theatre. It’s a fundamental misreading of Tolkien to cynically stretch his children’s farce about war & greed into a corporate tie-in blockbuster epic—every gesture to Lord of the Rings is embarrassing, and the rest is weightless, lazy garbage. This has value in a sort of meta way, I guess, as a desperate cry for the importance of pre-production. Watched the extended edition out of a morbid curiosity for what could’ve possibly hit the cutting room floor of the longest movie ever made but it turns out you can’t even tell because the whole trilogy feels like one long deleted scene anyway.

   1,538 24
9. K

   kylie 2026年8月23日

   my mom claims that thorin looks just like justin timberlake and only refers to legolas as “my man”

   1,016 6
10. E

    eely 2026年8月23日

    farewell👋 master burglar👨 go back to your books 📚 and your armchair🪑 plant your trees 🌲 watch them grow 😭

    2,451 4
11. E

    Evan 2026年8月23日

    The friend-zone is a bitch, isn’t it Legolas?

    2,660 8
12. M

    Mikael Stånggren 2026年8月23日

    The world is changed. I feel it in the water. I feel it in the earth. I smell it in the funky air of my local HFR theatre. Much that once was is lost, for no director now lives who remembers its subtle epicness. It began with the forging of The Lord of the Rings trilogy and the great feels that followed. Three feels were given to the Elves; immortal, wisest and fairest of all beings. Seven to the Dwarf Lords, great miners and craftsmen of the mountain halls. And nine, nine feels were gifted to the Race of Men, who above all else desire a dark and well-made fantasy saga. But they were all of them deceived, for another…

    2,169 79
13. D

    Dr Nostromo 2026年5月30日

    83/100

    Events have now culminated into a war between dwarves, humans, elves and two armies of orcs. This is such an exciting film that fails miserably in the theatrical version. I believe that much of its negative reaction is simply because of the continuity errors and rushed nature of the theatrical version …like they’re in a hurry to get it over with. Entire action sequences weren’t included to satisfy a PG rating and for length. I personally hate the theatrical version but the extended version rocks, even when its silly with its unrealistic action fx! Pure popcorn delight. — DrNostromo.com

14. C

    CinemaSerf 2025年5月29日

    After a singularly slow start to the series and despite the fact that I still can’t quite engage with Martin Freeman’s title character, I reckon that this is the best of the trilogy with some superb visual effects underpinned by a solid and characterful story right from the start. With the marauding “Smaug” breathing fire all over the town, it falls to “Bard” (Luke Evans) to try to save the day. Meantime, “Bilbo” (Freeman) is having to contend with the increasingly megalomaniacal dwarf king “Thorin” (Richard Armitage) who is suffering from a golden equivalent of snow-blindness that is testing the loyalties of his friends and allies alike, risking conflict with the now seriously narked Elven army of “Thranduil” (Lee Pace). With battle lines drawn, a siege looks inevitable and with dwarves and elves at loggerheads there could be only one, sinister and malevolent, winner waiting in the wings. This story is now taking us closer to the realms of the LOTR stories and the overlapping storylines help put much more meat on the bones of many of the characters – a benefit of doing the second story before the first, cinematically. There’s still no getting away from the fact the some of the acting talent here is at best a bit lacklustre and at times the likes of Aidan Turner and Messrs. Freeman, Armitage and Evans make even Orli Bloom look like a potential BAFTA winner. Luckily, though, there are the sonorous dulcets of the imposing Sir Ian McKellen, Cate Blanchett and Sir Christopher Lee to add some gravitas to the stunning photography and effects that complement well the fire-breathing dragon, the swordplay, the building sense of malevolence and mistrust and, of course, the formidable battle scenes with just about everyone from Middle Earth fighting for survival or domination. It’s probably the only one of the triptych that hits the ground running and effortlessly sustains it’s lengthy duration and if you can settle down to watch it on a big screen that does justice to the imagery and to Howard Shore’s musical imagination then this is well worth it.

15. R

    r96sk 2021年2月22日

    Exactly what it says on the tin – to a fault.

    Don’t get me wrong, I like it. However, towards the end ‘The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies’ definitely begins to drag quite heavily – the impact of what eventually happens did not, to be honest, hit as strongly as it could’ve/should’ve. The pure action is good, but there’s not much to remember about everything else.

    None of the characters, with the exception of Richard Armitage (Thorin) and Luke Evans (Bard) I guess, stand out amidst the wall-to-wall battle. Martin Freeman (Bilb), Ian McKellen (Gandalf) & Co. are are of little importance really, which is a shame.

    ‘The Hobbit’ series, unfortunately, gets inferior as it goes by. Loved the first film, enjoyed the second but this third installment – while passable – leaves me with a feeling of wanting something else from it. Happy to have watched them though, I’d still recommend them for sure.

16. G

    Gimly 2019年1月20日

    Comparing the _Lord of the Rings_ trilogy and the _Hobbit_ trilogy was already like comparing apples and mediocre oranges, but none so mediocre as _Battle of the Five Armies_. Don’t get me wrong, I love a “battle” as much as the next guy, more maybe, I don’t even mind a movie that’s 95% battle, but in this? It does. Not. Work.

    _Five Armies_ is a movie that never made it out of pre-viz, let alone to a polished, well-rounded, final cut. I enjoy it to some degree when running through a Middle-Earth marathon as a whole, but only when the group I’m with will let me roll my eyes and complain about it.

    _Final rating:★★½ – Had a lot that appealed to me, didn’t quite work as a whole._

17. D

    Dark Jedi 2018年1月6日

    The Lord of The Rings are still occupying the three top places of my top ten movies list. Needless to say I am a fan of Tolkien and his Middle Earth fantasy story. I never felt that The Hobbit series could match the original trilogy but then much of the story in The Hobbit is not really Tolkien’s but produced by Hollywood scriptwriters to embellish the story enough to fill three movies. It is not a bad attempt by any means (for being a Hollywood one) but it does not really reach the heights of The Lord of The Rings.

    Still, I quite liked these movies. They are good adventure, fantasy, special effects movies. Thus it saddened me when I went to IMDb and the first things I saw was a bunch of people shouting crap and giving it one star reviews. That is just so much rubbish. This is the third movie and it is not vastly different from the others. If you disliked the first ones so much why go and see this one? Also, the harping about not following the book. At this point that is a nonsense argument. It was fairly obvious that it was not going to follow the book in detail when it was announced that there were going to be three movies and if you did not get it then then you should have gotten it from the other two movies. One star ratings looks more like trolling to me.

    Anyway, back to the movie itself. I definitely liked this movie better than the second one. It was on par with the first one for me. There was less silly stuff, less stuff that just felt like fillers and the special effects were generally good.

    The story and the implementation is, as I wrote, less filled with fillers as the last movie. At least from my point of view. Still though, the story is not at all up to the standard of the original Tolkien works. It shows that it is a Hollywood product that favors effects and quantity before depth and quality. The battle at the end was epic but at the same time somewhat nonsensical in how people ran back and forth clobbering people and beasts right left and center. I did quite like the ramming troll though.

    I have to say that I did not like that weasel Alfrid. Sure he was meant to be disliked but he got tiresome rather quickly. He could have been left out after being pushed into the water as far as I am concerned. After that I just got annoyed every time he appeared and I got especially annoyed by the fact that everyone, even Gandalf, seemed to trust him to actually do what he was told. I was hoping all the way to the finishing scenes that he would meet a gruesome end.

    On the whole I definitely liked this movie. It had a “Tolkienesque” athmosphere, decent acting, decent story and loads and loads of special effects. Even though it does not reach the heights of The Lord of The Rings it is definitely great entertainment for the fantasy, not to mention special effects, lovers.

18. A

    Andres Gomez 2015年2月6日

    As there was not much more to be told from the end of the previous movie, just assist to more than 2h of continuous battle.

    Quite pointless, but you may enjoy the action if that is what you were looking for …