Sobibor 2018

影评 (12)

1. W

   Waldo 2026年8月22日

   In Nazi occupied Poland there was an extermination camp called Sobibor. There the guards of the third Reich were having the time of their lives. Drinking, killing, robbing, just having fun killing Jewish people. Amongst them were Russian jews that were dead set on escaping by systematically killing every guard in that camp. I’ve never seen nazis having so much fun being nazis. Jesus. There’s a scene involving wagons and people pulling on them like horses while the guards drunkenly are in the back whipping them that I thought I was not gonna make it. It’s pure cruelty, perversion, madness in a seemingly endless scene. Last hour is hard to shake. A reminder that these stories are more relevant than ever.

   11
2. M

   Matt Thomas 2026年8月22日

   A very well made, tasteful yet still harrowing recount of a remarkable and tragic piece of history. The actors are really put through the wringer – despite the careful way the director doesn’t exploit or sensationalise any scene.

   6 4
3. C

   cinnamon gwendolyn 2026年8月22日

   i wanted to see less violence against jews and more nazis being killed

   12 1
4. K

   Kuna 2026年8月22日

   Next time, try casting polish actors for roles that require speaking polish (even if it’s just a few sentences), damn it.

   19 2
5. F

   Felix Zilich 2026年8月22日

   В первой половине фильма Хабенский-режиссер уверенным почерком будущего классика кинобомбит каждую сцену. Сначала убивает в первые же десять минут актрису, ради которой я взялся смотреть ленту. Признаюсь честно, еще минут сорок верил, что она вернётся. Но это была лишь разминка. Спустя еще пять минут Хабенский начисто снёс четвертую стену, ворвавшись в кадр, спустив штаны и показав всем хер. В гробовой тишине было слышно как ему аплодируют с небес Никита Сергеич и Пауль Верхувен. Четвертая стена окончательно осыпалась, когда во время оскаровского монолога коменданта Френцеля, Кристофер Ламберт внезапно замолк, обернулся и вдруг увидел как на него в окно зырит Хабенский-режиссёр. Здесь аплодировать начал даже я. Очень интересный кинодебют. Без грамма иронии говорю.

   13 2
6. D

   Des Saint 2026年8月22日

   This is a Russian version of the most famous mass escape from a German extermination camp, Sobibor in Poland near Lublin. In it’s seventeen months of operation, approximately 180,000 people were killed there. On October 14th, 1943, a Jewish Russian POW, Alexander Pechersky organized a mass escape from the camp. Out of 600prisoners in the camp , half escaped but only 50 survived the war. Alexander managed to survive, but do to Stalin’s policy on Russian POW’s, he was sent to fight in a penal frontline battalion for the duration of the war. He also managed to survive that hell. He was truly an extraordinary hero and was finally honored by Putin posthumously in 2016 by being rewarded with the Order Of Courage.

   23
7. A

   Andy Fell 2026年8月22日

   DuBFal-War-Weeks – 1st Round – Film Nr.10 – Sobibor 1943, während des 2.Weltkriegs, spielen sich in Sobibor – einem KZ in Polen – unfassbare Szenen ab. Sobibor ist ein Todeslager, ein Vernichtungslager, in dem russische Kriegsgefangene und Juden unter menschenunwürdigenden Verhältnisse ihrem Ende entgegen vegetieren. Familien werden getrennt, die Männer zur Zwangsarbeit verdonnert, die Frauen zum Duschen geschickt. Aber aus der Brause kommt kein Wasser, sondern Gas … 😱. Und draußen am Fenster klotzt einer und schaut sich an, wie die Menschen drin verrecken 🤮. Die Gefangenen werden zu Spielzeug, zu Marionetten der deutschen Offiziere. Da kann es schon mal passieren, dass völlig ohne Grund alle Gefangenen sich in Reihen aufstellen müssen und dann ertönt der Befehl: “Jeder 10. wird…

   31
8. ꩜

   ꩜𝗹𝗼𝘁𝘂𝘇 2026年8月22日

   Boring

   7
9. E

   E. B. Anderson 2026年8月22日

   It’s an hour and a half of torture porn with maybe 15 minutes of plotting and 15 minutes of revenge porn. Other commenters have called this “tasteful” but I don’t see it. It’s an exploitation flick. The Russians must be stupid as hell to think this B-movie worse than I Spit on Your Grave is worthy of an Oscar. Pathetic.

   11
10. E

    Elmandarino 2026年8月22日

    Sadism without a heart. And plot.

    5
11. ʏ

    ʏᴏᴜɴᴇss_5xᴅ 2026年8月22日

    Good movie about a prison escape during the war

    6
12. S

    Scotty Walter 2026年8月22日

    Based on the true story of the Sobibor death camp during WWII. Just average as cinematic storytelling, but is a necessary film so that Nazism is never glamorized. Authoritarian regimes are on the rise in the 21st Century. Anything that shows how despicable extremist radicalism can be, and what it can lead to, is a good thing. Will be too violent and intense for many, but the film shows the courage of the camp prisoners in the face of wanton Nazi cruelty. Again, any film that reminds us to never consider supporting fascist ideology is a worthwhile endeavor.

    6