Hostiles 2017

影评 (92)

1. S

   ScreeningNotes 2026年8月23日

   There’s something fundamentally misguided about these types of stories. The implication of a tale where a racist is reformed by spending time with someone he hates is that the reason racists still exist in the world today is that they simply haven’t had the right life experiences, rather than that there are systemic conditions that manufacture and preserve racist sentiments. We’re supposed to believe that Captain Joseph J. Blocker (Christian Bale) simply hates Native Americans because he hasn’t been forced to transport one across the country yet, not because the United States spreads anti-aboriginal hatred to justify its existence as a nation on another culture’s land. No. That’s just not how it works. The reason people are racist is institutional,…

   1,048 110
2. J

   Josh Lewis 2026年8月23日

   Scott Cooper makes Capital-A American Dramas that are as narratively, thematically and politically complex as a Michael Bay film but because he does them in a laborious macho art weepy style instead of an ugly crass explosion I guess I’m supposed to take them seriously. This time he does the Good Colonialist story where the white man’s burden and guilt have a chance to act out extreme violence, not that it matters because the only thing Cooper knows how to do is steal his generic, empty-calorie genre stylings from much better filmmakers (previously Scorsese with Black Mass, here Ford and all the somber revisionist western filmmakers in conversation with his images) and get otherwise good performers to mumble about rote…

   536 21
3. L

   Logan Kenny 2026年8月23日

   cosmic brain level racism

   222 14
4. M

   matt lynch 2026年8月23日

   Mostly on autopilot. Like I was thinking it was weird that Ben Foster wasn’t in this and then yep, Ben Foster shows up. Anyway there are lots of guys who shouldn’t be taking a pass at THE SEARCHERS and Scott Cooper is definitely one of them.

   171 3
5. R

   russman 2026年8月23日

   Good thing they brought the shovels

   201
6. D

   David Sims 2026年8月23日

   Gloppy revisionist western that’s half as smart as it thinks it is, and twice as grim as it needs to be. Strong ending that’s just ridiculously unearned. Scott Cooper!!! *shakes fist at sky*

   187 5
7. ˗

   ˗ˏˋ suspirliam ˊˎ˗ 2026年8月23日

   came for timmy 🤭 stayed for rosamund pike in a cowboy hat and that big yeeHAW cinnamon tography 😍

   246
8. D

   davidehrlich 2026年8月23日

   “Hostiles,” a sturdy and characteristically brutal new Western from “Black Mass” director Scott Cooper, begins with somebody shooting a baby — that’s not a spoiler, just a warning. The year is 1892, and a settler named Rosalee Quaid (Rosamund Pike) is teaching her young daughters about the magical power of adverbs. Suddenly, their New Mexico homestead is raided by a band of Comanche renegades. They murder her husband, they shoot her two girls, and they fire a bullet directly into her infant son; Rosalee carries the lifeless bundle in her arms for days, because it’s that kind of movie — the only kind that Cooper knows how to make. READ THE FULL REVIEW ON INDIEWIRE

   161 4
9. R

   roks 2026年8月23日

   landscape porn where christian bale just takes a giant bite out of a whole lemon

   522 3
10. S

    Sean Gilman 2026年8月23日

    Hostiles boasts the greatest collection of Native American acting talent in a Hollywood film in years, with Wes Studi, Adam Beach and Q’orianka Kilcher, yet it can’t think of more than a few words for any of them to say. Their role is to humanize the white people, and to forgive them. And then they are no longer required. Review at Seattle Screen Scene.

    251 2
11. S

    Steve Lovecraft 2026年8月23日

    Cormac McCarthy’s western epic Blood Meridian or the Evening Redness in the West is an obtuse and nearly insurmountable story to commit to screen, and I have my doubts that if it ever is produced that it will properly encapsulate the themes and poetic depth of that novel. But I can appreciate when a movie scratches the surface, and Hostiles is definitely one of those films. In it, Christian Bale is a U.S. Cavalry officer tasked with escorting a Cheyenne war chief back to his tribal home in Montana before the chief succumbs to cancer. To make things worse, the two of them had been at Wounded Knee, and there is a deep-seated hatred stemming from decades of violence that…

    196 7
12. T

    tru 2026年8月23日

    2017: the year of timothèe

    445 6
13. M

    Mani0511 2026年8月21日

    Un film poignant, émouvant et tellement réaliste… Magnifique

14. T

    The SkillerZ 2026年8月21日

    Sedih

    1
15. L

    Lucas377 2026年8月20日

    Un western sombre qui se veut diffèrent des autres films de son genre par son point de vue progressiste sur la question indienne notamment. J’ai été abasourdi par l’immense prestation de Bale et par la photographie.

    1
16. Q

    Qmarcks1750 2026年8月20日

    I like the complexity of each character and their relationships and how the tragedy of the fighting between Native Americans and Americans affected them. I like that it shows that in the end most people on both sides didn’t really enjoy the brutality they had in each other, even if it meant Americans taking over.

    1
17. R

    rayan_ndj 2026年8月20日

    Le film est un cliché wow mdrrr, merci à Bale pour son acting et Pike, bien sur merci aux paysages et à la photographie ! Sinon le film ou le western est ce qu’on peut appeler ça un westen jsp. Le film qui veux réellement faire office de pardon sur ce que les américains ont fait aux autochtones, la demande de pardon est à chier !

18. A

    Aishken 2026年8月20日

    8+

19. G

    gadkoprakelula 2026年8月19日

    потрясающая история искупления, стандартная история для своего жанра. пока что это был лучший перформанс бэйла, я в него очень сильнт поверил. еще и каст отличный: джесси племонс, розамунд пайк, фрэнчи тимоти шаламе, джонатан мейджорс и другие. кристиан бэйл тут суровый суворняк, который жрет лимоны как яблоки и причмокивает воду, и видно он очень многое испытал. как и вся его команда. у него еще усы ахуенные фильм отлично снят, внимание держит, кадры сок. слышал, что челики приебываються к тому, что типо…

    4
20. G

    Gieres 2026年8月19日

    Beautiful movie, psychological post war story. Bale had a great performance but in my opinion I feel like they didn’t give that same opportunity for the rest of the cast, especially the Native American side of post war. Also fairly slow several times but it’s a stunning movie visually.

    1
21. T

    Takadox 2026年8月19日

    Ben foster is super underrated. His acting style reminds me so much of Sean Penn.

22. 𝑴

    𝑴𝑼𝑺𝑻𝑶𝑬𝑽𝑺𝑲𝒀 🇮🇶 2026年8月19日

    2024 شهر العاشر شفت نص ساعة من الفيلم ، وكلت بعدين اختمه. اليوم ختمته.

    4 1
23. H

    HaterDoTimotheeChalamet Heinzelmann Couto 2026年8月18日

    É bom tirando esse tal de timothee chalamet que ESTRAGOU TOTALMENTE O FILME

24. 8

    89odev 2026年8月18日

    I adore this unhurried style of filmmaking, where the important things are unsaid.

25. M

    Murtadh Amin 2026年8月18日

    imma sucker for native-centric films and the progression of bale’s character to ultimately risking his life for the cheyenne chief was just insane and perfect ending…top 10 fav films

26. B

    Brooks_J 2026年8月18日

    What a total waste of potential. Overegged melodramatic mess. The performances are great, the cinematography is beautiful, I just think it’s misspent on bad direction and a bad script. There is more pathos in John Wayne standing in that doorway at the end of the Searchers than there is of any five minute sequence of Rosamund Pike and Christian Bale screaming, gnashing their teeth and tearing at the dirt with their bare hands. Just shoots for completely unearned drama and…

    1
27. V

    Vibin Francis 2026年8月18日

    Hostiles is a raw and deeply emotional movie. It feels very real and heavy, with great acting and a lot of emotion. Not just a Western, but a story about pain, hatred, and humanity.

    2
28. M

    Made of Monsters 2026年8月18日

    dramatic, violent, beautiful. the mustache situation looks good on bale. the movie occasionally veers into melodrama and saccharine music territory, but balances that out with a good amount of grit.

    1
29. K

    kylrck 2026年8月18日

    it was nice but i feel like i dont completely get it ok i read more reviews and i did get it its just not that great a story rip timmy

30. N

    Ntlie.a 2026年8月18日

    Känner att jag knappt har sett western filmer så gav de en chans, helt okej måste jag säga. We like Christian Bale. Nästa western få bli nån klassisk!

31. M

    MCFUMIGENE 2026年8月18日

    Pas mon Chalamax 💔 Le film démarre comme “Il était une fois dans l’ouest” mais n’atteint jamais la même justesse. J’ai trouvé la manière d’aborder les thèmes comme la culpabilité ou le racisme très anachronique, ce qui m’a beaucoup sorti du film. Heureusement il existe des beaux plans de Christian Bale face au deuil, nombreux car il est vraiment nul pour protéger sa troupe..

32. W

    Willy_Shake 2026年8月18日

    4 stars for the cinematography and 3 stars for the actual movie/story.

33. C

    Chris McKinnon-Smith 2026年8月18日

    Great western. Christian Bale & Rosamund Pike deliver solid performances. Intense film.

34. N

    ninety6 2026年8月18日

    Scott Cooper is not exactly a director I have any consistent faith in but considering that this and Out of the Furnace are two of my favorite Bale performances I wonder if I should actually give Pale Blue Eye a chance. Really moving and effectively brutal but I can’t totally shake the bad taste of white (anti-)heroics overshadowing much of any internalizing of the female/indigenous characters who mostly exist to be stalwart representations of serenity through suffering; even despite initial…

    1
35. Y

    Yetcha 2026年8月17日

    Grosse déception… Si le départ est sur des chapeaux de roues, la suite est moins prenante, notamment à la moitié du film où, la vengeance assouvie fait que le reste n’a plus grand intérêt. Curieux d’avoir choisit ce rythme de narration qui plombe le film alors qu’on aurait souhaiter se développer la relation entre Bale et Pike. Tant pis, j’attendais un nouveau western, moderne est fort mais il n’en ressort qu’un film plutôt très moyen

36. W

    WormWater2 2026年8月17日

    Reminds me of All In The Family ❤️

37. A

    alex005 2026年8月17日

    the shit i watch for Timothee Chalamet

38. J

    Jason DiPaola 2026年8月17日

    Kind of a crazy stacked cast Had no idea half of them were in this

    2
39. B

    brycegeen 2026年8月17日

    Christian Bale does another Western. And that should be enough to want to watch it.

    1
40. _

    _Ewan__ 2026年8月17日

    Ce serait pas le meilleur western de ses dernières années ? Chritian Bale exceptionnel et que dire de Rosamund Pike qui portent tout les deux le film, les thèmes abordés sont vraiment intéressants comme comme le regret de ses actes passés, la haine, le racisme, la colonisation, la rédemption et le suicide ce qui est vraiment peu commun dans un western Par contre Y’a un seul français dans ce film comme par hasard c’est le premier à mourir mdrrrr -1 étoile pour le manque de respect à chalamet

41. I

    il_ouuu 2026年8月17日

    Classique quoi #americain

42. V

    VincentDubois 2026年8月17日

    Très fréquentés ces grands espaces!

43. S

    Seby0027 2026年8月16日

    Sans être marquant, c’est un bon film

44. S

    sebsxc 2026年8月16日

    Acting fou , Timothee salameche j’aime bien Merci pour ça

45. N

    nina_rggr 2026年8月16日

    Shout out to that random lady that clocked out colonialists behavior in the middle of dinner My interest in this movie lasted as long as Timothé Chalamet screen time (which is not a lot) On est dans Koh Lanta ou quoi ils ont pris “à la fin il n’en restera qu’un” un peu trop au sérieux Sentimental shot filming the chief’s back My dad: il fait pipi ihihihi

46. A

    A7MD 2026年8月16日

    مو مره جوي الويسترن بس قلت بشوفه لعيون كريستيان بيل وطبعاً ماخذلني بس انصدمت الفلم مو ويسترن الي كنت اتوقعه اكشن وبس في جانب إنساني عميق بس ما انكر كان في طاخ وطيخ بس مو بشكل أساسي. قصة الفلم جنود أمريكيين يضطرون يرافقون قائد من الهنود الحمر وعائلته لبلدهم مع كل اللي صار بينهم من حروب وكراهية تبدأ علاقتهم تتغير. تغير شخصية جو جباار من سنين وهو شايل كراهية وحقد بسبب الحروب مع الهنود الحمر ومع الرحلة تتغير نظرته بشكل…

    36 14
47. A

    Astrid𖦹 2026年8月16日

    I was so disappointed to see Timothee Chalamet appear on screen and then incredibly happy to see his character killed within like five minutes. Christian Bale and Rosamund Pike delivers outstanding performances as expected. This was such a tragic story yet somehow a bit weird for kind of justifying the former racists actions because he becomes friends with the natives, but once they are all cool with eachother all the natives are killed? And the natives have like a total…

48. N

    Nurtas1 2026年8月16日

    feels like a reading boring book

49. R

    Rasbot 2026年8月15日

    Mid western movie, then again I dont really like western movies. Cinematography was really good.

50. S

    sergey_alya 2026年8月15日

    Второй фильм с Кристианом Бэйлом, в котором он должен куда-то доставить ненавистного ему персонажа, а персонаж за время в дороге проникается к главному герою и не то чтобы переходит на его сторону, но … А, ну и +- дикий запад В общем, такое мне нравится

51. D

    dhaval1 2026年8月15日

    Hidden gem

52. L

    Laki 2026年8月15日

    Apsolutni bioskop, odličan

    3
53. T

    texto junge 2026年8月15日

    when the final shootout scene so retarded it ruins the whole experience

54. K

    Khaled Mohamed 2026年8月15日

    العجوز الي في اخر الفيلم اكيد صهيوني No one really wins a war

    11 2
55. S

    SnozTeach 2026年8月14日

    Malgré une mauvaise compagnie, super séance, une tension forte des acteurs investi et un scénario intéressant

56. M

    Mr Black 2026年8月14日

    في عام 1892، يُكلَّف ضابط في الجيش الأمريكي بمهمة إجبارية: مرافقة زعيم قبيلة من السكان الأصليين، كان عدوًا له وللجيش طوال سنوات، من نيو مكسيكو إلى مونتانا الرحلة تجمع أشخاصًا بينهم تاريخ طويل من الكراهية والعنف، ويضطرون للسفر معًا وسط أراضٍ خطرة.٠ • • • صراحة، كنت متحمس أتابع الفيلم من أول، ومع ذلك ما توقعت إنه بيعجبني وينال على تقديري لهذي الدرجة. الفيلم من الخارج يوحي إنه مجرد فيلم ويسترن، لكن اللي يحتويه أعمق بكثير. قصة مليانة مواضيع ورسائل…

    14 4
57. S

    smailgsii173 2026年8月14日

    About a man with a heart of stone from war forced to escort his enemy on a journey across a barren land Every step in it holds dust, hunger and the memory of death The silence in it is heavy because it’s full of old hatred and new fear There are no clear heroes and no clear villains. Everyone is wounded in their own way It’s not a war movie It’s a film about how humanity can be born even among enemies

    17
58. A

    antoGOAT27 2026年8月14日

    Très prenant

59. S

    SAM3Q 2026年8月14日

    “Do not look to the past my friend for a part of me will die with you” 💔 فيلم درامي غرب أمريكي ملحمي الفيلم مرثية سينمائية جميلة مظلومة قدم المخرج سكوت كوبر تحفه فنية من تصوير بصري ومشاهد الصامت 🎵 والموسيقى التصويرية الأداء التمثيلي رهيب من كذا شخصية كريستيان بيل قدم واحد من أقوى أدوار الصمت والتعبيرات بالعيون والوجه من مشهد نظراته لي الزعيم يلو هوك ومشهد الصراخ الصامت 😢💔 روزاموند بايك من المشهد الافتتاحي قدمة أداء مرعب ومشهد حفر…

    11 10
60. B

    berat433454 2026年8月13日

    Biraz sıkıcı ama güzeldi Christian bale ın olduğu bi filmin kötü olması zor zaten

    2
61. S

    SmokeyMcpot44 2026年8月13日

    Christian Bale top tier , new age western also top tier. Something about the rawness of this movie and the gritty American start up feeling of the Wild West

62. T

    ToshiroMifunv 2026年8月13日

    Christian Bale est méconnaissable dans ce rôle, il lui colle à la peau, le regard, les expressions faciales, c’est du grand art pour lui. Le film quant à lui est brutal mais réaliste, de la haine à la rédemption, il m’a énormément plu.

    1
63. A

    Alfie Whittaker 2026年8月13日

    “A part of me dies with you” Beautiful film! One of the best Modern Westerns ive ever watched

64. M

    meena04 2026年8月13日

    I’m glad I watched this, but I’m fine never watching it again. The acting was great and the cinematography and directing were beautiful but oof..

    1
65. M

    Mfaure82 2026年8月13日

    Film âpre et cru sur les ravages de la conquête de l’Ouest. Sur le pardon, le deuil, la colère et l’hypothèse de se relever de tout. Un casting conséquent et une Rosamund Pike bluffante, surtout après une telle scène d’ouverture. Esthétiquement réussi comme film. Ça ne te met pas forcément en joie en revanche.

66. B

    BoxwellBoatman 2026年8月13日

    Absolutely brutal, emotionally taxing film. Beautifully shot and steeped in a genre romanticizing Manifest Destiny, while clearly intent to ground its characters in horrible reality. I don’t know if I’ll ever need to watch this film again, as its atrocities have left such a strong impression I can’t see forgetting it anytime soon. I’ve never given Rosamund Pike enough credit, and she made a fan out of me by making the most out of a difficult role. Christian Bale turned in a lunchpail-like stellar performance, and Jesse Plemons similar on showed himself (again) as the type of actor who can add to any scene.

67. D

    DataaM12 2026年8月13日

    One of the best movies I have ever seen,the perfect mix of character development,music and cinematography.

    1
68. F

    Ferreira 2026年8月12日

    gosto bastante dessas atmosferas de filme western, a fotografia e a trilha sonora foram ótimas, e também uma baita atuação do Christian Bale, mas infelizmente a história em si não me pegou muito o desenvolvimento foi lento demais para mim, queria que tivessem explorado mais os personagens, para que pudéssemos entendê-los melhor, apesar de ter alguns momentos bem marcantes senti uma falta de conexão emocional tirando o protagonista, parece que não deram presença de verdade aos personagens, tudo pareceu muito vazio…

    3
69. A

    Adiponectine 2026年8月12日

    Un Batman à pornstache

70. S

    SiriusOutlaw 2026年8月12日

    Stellar visuals, incredible casting. Painstakingly slow burn, which knocks it down a notch for me. Overall, a solid movie you won’t want to watch again for another 10 years.

71. P

    Poissouye 2026年8月12日

    C’est vraiment pas mal, Christian Bale est excellent. Ça aurait mérité un peu plus d’action Christian Bale est vraiment très fort

72. K

    Kaerou_32 2026年8月12日

    Super slow. And sloppily executed narrative imo. If the aim was to humanise Native Americans why go with this angle. I compared and contrasted a lot with Killers of the Flower Moon while watching and it really highlights to me how flat this depiction is. The message here is “Native Americans are humans who deserve respect.” Yeah ik, and? Spent more time going into justice and even then it remained fairly surface level. I do like the mutual respect that grows between Blocker and Yellow Hawk though. The most western aspect of the movie imo.

73. М

    м. нэв 2026年8月11日

    decent propaganda (don’t let native americans watch this)

74. C

    Chenivresse 2026年8月11日

    Un western ?? Que je connaissais pas ??? J’avais hâte avant de regarder. Bah comme quoi faut pas avoir hâte dans la vie. Bon les natives sont méchants et violents mais en fait dans leur nature il y a autre chose vous comprenez ?? Les américains sont violents mais c’est leur métier ils avaient pas le choix ils sont gentils et regardez ils savent punir les américains méchants oulalala Bouh on s’aime pas fin il y a peut être des…

    1
75. J

    Jack Cornes 2026年8月11日

    I have tried so hard with Westerns, whether it be the Dollars Trilogy, Unforgiven, Open Range, 3:10 to Yuma (need to try that one again actually) or True Grit but I just can’t enjoy them. I think the western aesthetic is very interesting and is an intriguing time in American history but I just couldn’t find a truly great western picture in my eyes. (Tarantino’s Django Unchained is a fine picture but I can’t call it truly great). That was…

76. K

    kmackle90 2026年8月11日

    Really well made movie and great acting and story.

77. R

    ridiculoid 2026年8月10日

    “our treatment of the natives cannot be forgiven…please accept this tobacco” 🫩🫩🫩

78. V

    Vino 2026年8月10日

    Starring “White Priveleges” cousin: “White Guilt”

79. M

    Matthew 2026年8月10日

    I get what this is going for. There are some shots in this and dialogue where I can really see what they are trying to get across but holy shit does it just fall flat on its face whenever you think about it for more than a minute. I’m so sick in this day and she of stories about native characters having the native characters be side characters. Boooooring

80. S

    swoods42 2026年8月10日

    Beautiful visuals matched with a disappointingly cliche story

81. A

    Arthur Bougouin 2026年8月10日

    Long poème introspectif

82. A

    Antifauteuil 2026年8月10日

    C’est beau et sans trop de dialogues inutiles toutefois l’angle est relou pour traiter le sujet. Le blanc qui change complètement et qui sauve les indigènes c’est un narratif assez relou à vrai dire

    1
83. M

    Mathylde 2026年8月10日

    Je suis dans ma période western, c’est une folie

84. T

    TheBigTingus 2026年8月10日

    Favorite part is that Timothee Chalamet is non-critical (still earlier in career). For some reason I feel that pisses him off more than not being in something. I’m not sure if I’ve felt this way about a movie before, but I had one overwhelming thought while watching it: this is visual poetry. In my mind, there’s an entire genre of poetry dedicated to capturing a feeling, and those feelings drive the narrative. Incomplete thoughts. Sensual descriptions. Simple adages. Meditative contemplations.…

85. M

    MightyJoeSal 2026年8月9日

    Two enemies learning to see each other as human beings and a bunch of landscape porn.

86. D

    dkuzmic 2026年8月8日

    Just such a shocking film. I genuinely think this is a well-made, captivating plot with great action sequences. I’ll admit that the social commentary unfortunately falls a little flat to me. Yet still, aside from the real world connection issues, the story is enjoyable to me. I think the interpersonal struggle that both Joe and Rosalie deal with seems compelling. The development of respect and the test of that respect at the end feels satisfying. Not to mention the constant…

    2
87. D

    duracelleur 2026年7月24日

    Puissance brute à la Max Richter musicalité et au Chalamet qui apparaît et qui (spoiler) fait zéro long feu. Du puissant bon!

88. D

    decflynn 2026年7月5日

    Ironically I think my most disliked genre is Westerns. You just know they are gonna have some form of racist protagonist and something about a man on a horse in desolation just doesn’t jump out to me generally. That being said, I have wanted to watch this film for ages because Christian Bale in a modern western? Okay I can get over my grumpiness to try it! I really appreciated how brutal and intention the opening of the film is.…

89. C

    Chris_Tof 2026年7月5日

    Scott Cooper nous offre un western sombre et profondément humain qui revisite les codes du genre à travers le prisme de la violence, du traumatisme et de la rédemption. Le film plonge dans l’Amérique de 1892 et suit un capitaine de l’armée contraint d’escorter un ancien chef cheyenne mourant à travers un territoire hostile. La mise en scène de Cooper impose une atmosphère pesante et contemplative, portée par des paysages grandioses et une photographie d’une grande puissance. Le scénario, volontairement…

90. V

    VerdictFirst 2023年12月1日

    Such a gutwreching film about grief and endurance with an excellent Christian Bale, Wes Studi and Rosemund Pike. Overall great cast, beautifully shot and great story. Such an underrated film.

91. M

    Matsvei Kastsiukou 2022年9月21日

    Christian Bale is incredible in this one. Probably one of the best films about cruelty and xenophobia that I’ve ever seen

92. Z

    zoetropic 2018年8月27日

    Contrived.